By Nicholas Dorsten, Esq.
What happens when a protective father goes too far? That is for the jury to decide...
LARGO — Dennis Hobbs is a father who wanted to keep tabs on his 18-year-old daughter because he worried that she was skipping school, smoking and having sex with her boyfriend.
But when St. Petersburg police found the worried father one night back in spring 2010, he was inside his car dressed in black, wearing face paint and a wig, near the abuse shelter where his daughter had gone to live. Inside the car was a loaded gun and detailed notebooks recording her activities.
So, in an unusual case, Hobbs was charged with stalking his own adult daughter and this week went on trial.
It's a strange case because of the goofy wig and the face paint, but in other ways it relates to an issue every parent faces — how far can you go to direct a child, even if she is now your adult child?
The defense attorney said the suspect was simply concerned for a wayward child and wanted to prevent her from making bad choices. He said it would almost criminal for him not to help her.
But the Assistant State Attorney said the protective father crossed the line into a criminal case of stalking, and detailed how the father kept approaching and bothering his adult daughter long after she asked him to stay away.
"What this case is about is control and limits," she said.
For her part, the daughter Lyndsay Hobbs, now 20, testified that after she learned how her father was dressed in the disguise and near the shelter where she was staying, "I felt more scared for my life than I've ever been."
She said the incident made her fear that "I could have been kidnapped that night and sent anywhere in the world."
The father is 60, and retired after working in computer programing and other technical matters for AT&T. He has no criminal record in Florida. He and his wife no longer live in the state, but they returned for the trial.
Lyndsay Hobbs is an artist who studied at the highly regarded Ringling College of Art and Design in Sarasota. But according to testimony this week, her father was concerned about her behavior when she was as young as 16.
He found a birth control pill in her room, disapproved of her boyfriend, believed she had been drinking and discovered risque comments she made on Facebook, which even she now acknowledges were inappropriate. She also was charged with shoplifting.
But prosecutors say the concerned father went too far. He came to see her at her job at a drug store against her will, and came uninvited more than once to her boyfriend's family's house, where she stayed for a time, witnesses testified. The daughter testified that she got a temporary injunction against her father "because he would not leave me alone." She moved into an abuse shelter to get away from him, and because "I felt more safe there."
But he even hired a private investigator and found her. He even knew somehow that she had bought a scooter while at the shelter, even though she never told him that.
He also wanted her to leave Ringling and move along with his wife out of state, saying she could continue her studies there.
After the man was arrested, police arranged for his daughter to make a secretly recorded phone call to him.
On the rather scratchy recording, which was played in court, she said she was scared of him because he kept stalking her. He denied stalking and said she had been lying.
"I just want to live my life," she said.
"You want to live a life of sex and drugs," he said. He told her he loved her.
Have you or someone you loved been arrested for a drug or a stalking charge? Then contact the law offices of Blake & Dorsten, P.A. to speak with an experienced Pinellas criminal defense lawyer now!
Our office is located at 4707 140th ave. N, Suite 107, Clearwater, FL 33762, across from the criminal courthouse and minutes from Tampa and St. Petersburg. You can contact your St. Petersburg criminal defense attorney by phone at 727.286.6141 or online at info@BlakeDorstenLaw.com.
I guess it takes a defense legal firm to tell the objective facts in a case like this. Thank you for doing so and hope you, like Denis deVlaming, keep defending the innocent that the media convict without due process. Of course, the Saint Petersburg Police help the media with their biased reports.
ReplyDeleteI would think your firm would enjoy
www.PICTYS.com
on how the SPPD works and the real facts of the case. But too bad this is not a site that thousands come to.
Last, no one won in this trial, I lost a daughter, she lost her chance at being a world class artist, poet and creative designer. I hope she will speak to me again soon, before she loses her chance, at only twenty. A father's love is forever, though she had put me through all this, over four years, I have never had a single "ill" thought toward her. She is my daughter; I am her father.